Christina Scherzer, BA MA

Graduate Public & Nonprofit-Management

Titel der Arbeit: 

Spillover Effects of Crises in the Nonprofit Sector

Statement:

"Time and again, we come across headlines about scandals or crises at nonprofit organizations. This raises a question for me: Do such incidents actually have an impact on other organizations that aren’t even directly affected by them? It is precisely this question—and many others—that I explored in my master’s thesis. I am all the more delighted that not only was I able to find answers to these questions, but my thesis has also been honored with the Master’s Thesis Award. For me, this special recognition is the perfect conclusion to my master’s program and shows me that the many hours of work and effort were more than worth it. Thank you very much for the award and to everyone who has accompanied and supported me along the way!”

Topic of the Master’s Thesis

The master’s thesis “Spillover Effects of Crises in the Nonprofit Sector” by Christina Scherzer examines the impact that crises at individual nonprofit organizations have on other organizations within the sector and the factors that influence these effects. The focus is on how scandals and crises affect the reputation, trust, funding, and actions of other nonprofit organizations.

The thesis thus addresses a highly topical issue that is equally relevant to both research and practice. At a time when nonprofit organizations are increasingly under public scrutiny and must meet rising demands for transparency and accountability, this study makes an important contribution to understanding sector-wide crisis dynamics. Particularly noteworthy is the original research approach, which links crisis management issues with aspects of trust, reputation, and accountability in the nonprofit sector. Methodologically, the study is based on 15 qualitative interviews with executives from various areas of the sector, which were analyzed using Mayring’s qualitative content analysis.

Key Findings

The findings show that spillover effects in the nonprofit sector pose a real challenge. In particular, crises and scandals involving prominent organizations can undermine trust in the entire sector and affect the perception, funding opportunities, and operating conditions of even those organizations that are not themselves affected by a crisis. Particularly insightful is the finding that the public often fails to distinguish between individual organizations, and that a loss of trust can therefore spread to the entire sector.

At the same time, this study illustrates that spillover effects do not exclusively have negative consequences. Crises can encourage reflection on internal processes, increase risk awareness, and trigger professionalization processes. Furthermore, the study shows that crises at other organizations can be used as learning opportunities and thus contribute to strengthening governance, control, and safeguards throughout the sector.

Practical Relevance

This study provides valuable insights for executives, board members, and decision-makers in the nonprofit sector. It makes clear that trust is a central resource for the legitimacy and funding of nonprofit organizations and has an impact far beyond individual organizations.

Of particular relevance are the practical conclusions regarding how to address requirements for accountability, transparency, and trust. The findings show that, in the future, organizations will rely even more heavily on professional crisis prevention, transparent communication, and the clear presentation of their social impact. Of particular note are the recommendations on impact reporting, crisis management, and sector-wide learning, which make an important contribution to securing credibility and trust in the long term.

Download Certificate